Nottingham House is a traditional pub in Sheffield's Broomhill area, renowned for its homemade pies and diverse drink selection. The establishment offers a variety of real ales and hosts events like live music and quiz nights, fostering a friendly and relaxed atmosphere. Its proximity to the University of Sheffield makes it a popular spot among students and locals alike.
What each source says
- Google 4.6 1,600
- Tripadvisor 4.5 239
Bar length is review volume, so you can see how much weight sits behind each score. Captured 2026-08-26.
What visitors single out
Liked
- Cozy and Traditional Pub Atmosphere The interior is described as both spacious and cozy, creating a warm and inviting environment reminiscent of a classic British pub.
- Dog-Friendly Establishment A welcoming environment for dog owners, allowing dogs in the public/sports bar area with water bowls available.
- Excellent Value for Money Customers consistently praise the generous portions and reasonable prices, making it an affordable and satisfying dining experience.
- Friendly and Efficient Staff The pub is known for its welcoming and helpful staff, who contribute to the overall positive atmosphere.
- Wide Selection of Delicious Pies The Nottingham House offers a vast array of homemade pies with generous fillings and a variety of options, including vegetarian choices, ensuring there's something for everyone.
Criticised
- Basic Interior While some find it charming, others suggest the pub could benefit from some upkeep and a slight spruce-up.
- Can Get Very Busy The pub's popularity often leads to overcrowding, making it difficult to find a table, especially during peak hours.
- Inconsistent Food Temperature Some reviewers have noted that the food, particularly the peas and chips, is not always served hot.
- Potential for Overdone Chips Some patrons have found the chips to be a bit too well-done on occasion.
- Service Can Be Slow Due to the high volume of customers, there can be long waits for food, particularly when the pub is busy.
The longer read
Nottingham House, affectionately known as "The Notty," is highly recommended for its outstanding homemade pies, offering a wide selection of fillings, including vegetarian options. Multiple reviewers rave about the generous portions, reasonable prices, and delicious flavor combinations. The steak and ale pie, steak and Stilton, and chicken and mushroom are frequently mentioned as favorites. The pastry is consistently described as perfect, and the pies are generously filled with tender, well-seasoned meats or flavorful vegetable combinations. Reviewers consistently praise the accompanying sides, especially the chips, often described as "proper" or "homemade" with a crispy exterior and fluffy interior. The mushy peas and gravy receive positive comments, with many appreciating the generous gravy portions. The value for money is consistently highlighted. Many reviewers advise arriving early, as the pub is popular and can get crowded, leading to potential waits for tables and food, and some pies sell out quickly. The pub has a classic, cozy interior, creating a warm and welcoming atmosphere. Staff members are frequently described as friendly, efficient, and helpful, contributing to a positive dining experience. While a few reviewers mentioned occasional inconsistencies in food temperature (e.g., cold mushy peas) or changes in chip quality, the overwhelming consensus is that Nottingham House offers an exceptional pie experience. Some reviewers suggest the pub could benefit from some upkeep or sprucing up. Some reviewers found the pub very busy, which made them feel unsafe. The pub's location near the university makes it a popular spot for students, but it also attracts locals and visitors alike. The presence of a pool table is noted as a plus by some. Overall, Nottingham House is considered a must-visit for pie lovers seeking a hearty, flavorful, and affordable meal in a traditional pub setting. The consistent quality and wide variety of pies make it a standout destination in Sheffield.
A synthesis of published third-party reviews. Not written by Breaks.
Getting there
- Phone
- +44 114 327 0508
- Website
- m.facebook.com/TheNottyHouse/?locale2=en_GB
| Mon | 12:00 - 0:00 |
|---|---|
| Tue | 12:00 - 0:00 |
| Wed | 12:00 - 0:00 |
| Thu | 12:00 - 0:00 |
| Fri | 12:00 - 1:00 |
| Sat | 12:00 - 1:00 |
| Sun | 12:00 - 0:00 |
Against the neighbourhood
Rated 4.6 against a median of 4.6 across the 17 places to eat we hold for Broomhill, where the most-reviewed is Turtle Bay Sheffield.
Still deciding?
- What are the most recommended homemade pies at Nottingham House for a first-time visitor?
- What types of real ales and other drinks are available at Nottingham House, and which are the most popular among patrons?
- Does Nottingham House host regular live music or quiz nights, and what days and times are these events typically held?
- When is the most lively or relaxed time to visit Nottingham House, considering student crowds and special events?
- What nearby sights or landmarks in Broomhill, such as the University of Sheffield or parks, can I explore before or after dining at Nottingham House?
What this page cannot tell you
- Descriptions and review summaries are supplied by the source index and are reproduced as published; they are not independently verified by Breaks.
- Ratings and review counts are point-in-time snapshots and drift constantly. Check the venue's own site or the rating provider for the current figure.
- Opening hours change seasonally and at short notice. Confirm with the venue before travelling.
- Category labels come from the source index and are occasionally wrong — a venue may be filed under a type that does not match how it trades.
- Straight-line distances understate real walking distance, especially where a river or railway sits between two points.