Pizza Pilgrims Carnaby is a pizzeria situated within Kingly Court, a vibrant three-storey dining destination in Soho, London. Established in 2014, it offers a nostalgic ambiance reminiscent of 1960s Naples, featuring eclectic decor and an open kitchen where patrons can observe the pizza-making process. The menu showcases a variety of traditional and inventive Neapolitan pizzas, crafted with high-quality Italian ingredients. In addition to pizzas, the eatery serves aperitivo and friggitoria (fried Italian street food) at its kiosk, available for takeaway or to enjoy while waiting. The restaurant accommodates both bookings and walk-ins, ensuring a welcoming experience for all guests.
What visitors single out
Liked
- Efficient, Fast Service The kitchen is well-regarded for speed, with many guests noting that their food arrives very quickly after ordering, making it ideal for those on a tight schedule.
- Exceptional Pizza Quality Many diners rave about the authentic Neapolitan-style pizza, praising the light, soft dough and high-quality, flavorful toppings like the popular double pepperoni with hot honey.
- Inclusive Menu Options The restaurant is highly regarded for catering to various dietary needs, specifically offering a solid selection of vegetarian choices and excellent, highly-rated gluten-free pizza options.
- Vibrant and Lively Atmosphere The restaurant offers a cozy, energetic, and typically upbeat environment, with both indoor and outdoor seating options that enhance the overall dining experience.
- Welcoming and Friendly Staff Multiple reviewers highlight the outstanding service, noting that staff members are often attentive, professional, and go out of their way to make guests feel at home.
Criticised
- Added Service Charges Guests should be aware that a 12.5% service charge is automatically added to the final bill, which some patrons may prefer to be optional or clearly disclosed upfront.
- Loud Noise Levels Due to the restaurant's popularity and compact design, the atmosphere can get quite loud, making it difficult to hold conversations at the table in larger groups.
- Occasional Service Oversights While generally efficient, some guests have noted instances where the rushed pace led to errors, such as forgotten drinks or occasional lapses in attentiveness.
- Strict Procedural Rules Some first-time visitors have found the staff's adherence to specific walk-in or seating rules to be somewhat rigid or even unfriendly if customers do not immediately understand the protocols.
- Tight Seating Arrangements Several diners report that the seating can feel cramped and crowded, which might make for a less comfortable or private dining experience during busy times.
The longer read
Pizza Pilgrims Carnaby consistently earns high praise for its authentic, high-quality Neapolitan-style pizza, with many patrons calling it some of the best they have had in London. The dough is frequently described as light, soft, and perfectly crafted, with standout menu items including the double pepperoni and honey pizza, the truffle and mushroom pizza, and the various gluten-free options, which are noted as being particularly impressive for those with dietary restrictions. Guests generally appreciate the diverse menu that balances classic Italian favorites with creative options like carbonara pizza, and many commend the refreshing homemade lemonades and garlic-heavy herb dips as excellent accompaniments to the meal. While the overwhelming majority of experiences are positive, a small minority of reviewers found specific dishes, such as the smoky aubergine, to be lacking in depth, and one visitor noted that some pizzas arrived under-topped or requiring extra seasoning. However, for most, the food quality remains the primary draw.
A synthesis of third-party reviews supplied by Mindtrip travel index. Not written by Breaks.
Getting there
- Phone
- +44 20 7287 2200
- Website
- pizzapilgrims.co.uk/pizzerias/carnaby/?utm_source=google&utm_medium=local&utm_campaign=gbplisting
| Mon | 11:30 - 23:00 |
|---|---|
| Tue | 11:30 - 23:00 |
| Wed | 11:30 - 23:00 |
| Thu | 11:30 - 23:00 |
| Fri | 11:30 - 23:00 |
| Sat | 11:30 - 23:00 |
| Sun | 11:00 - 21:00 |
Against the neighbourhood
Rated 4.8 against a median of 4.5 across the 1,957 places to eat we hold for London, where the most-reviewed is The O2.
Still deciding?
- Which pizza is considered the signature or must‑try item at Pizza Pilgrims Carnaby?
- How long is the typical wait for a table during lunch or dinner at Pizza Pilgrims Carnaby, and does the venue offer bar‑style seating?
- What is the price range for a standard Neapolitan pizza and for a speciality pizza at this venue?
- Does the open kitchen allow guests to watch the pizza being tossed and cooked, and how does this impact the dining experience?
- What other eateries or attractions are within walking distance of Kingly Court that a tourist could combine with a meal at Pizza Pilgrims?
Where this comes from
Venue records are drawn from the Mindtrip travel index, which aggregates place data and review signals from Google Places, Tripadvisor and booking providers. Ratings are reproduced per source rather than merged into a single number. Distances to nearby venues are computed here as great-circle distances between the published coordinates, not walking or driving routes. Comparison figures are medians computed across the venues we hold for the same neighbourhood or city.
Source: Mindtrip travel index, captured 2026-08-21.
What this page cannot tell you
- Descriptions and review summaries are supplied by the source index and are reproduced as published; they are not independently verified by Breaks.
- Ratings and review counts are point-in-time snapshots and drift constantly. Check the venue's own site or the rating provider for the current figure.
- Opening hours change seasonally and at short notice. Confirm with the venue before travelling.
- Category labels come from the source index and are occasionally wrong — a venue may be filed under a type that does not match how it trades.
- Straight-line distances understate real walking distance, especially where a river or railway sits between two points.